MUST BE 18 OR OLDER - MUST READ TERMS OF SERVICE You Are On: Forum
 
View RSS Feed

Webmaster

Prison Myths

Rate this Entry
by , 03-22-2011 at 10:04 PM (1135 Views)
America is obsessed with "tough on inmate" policies. Elected and appointed officials seem to usually come down on the side of austere conditions and treatment for the incarcerated when given a choice. Blowhard politicians speak from their bully pulpits about how inmates “don’t need better conditions” and “don’t need more rights.” The media routinely use the worst inmate possible to put a face on any issue. After all, it’s about selling stories these days, not telling them. Indeed, even Charles Manson has become the face of cellphones in prison because he has been caught with one. Many Americans are even convinced that “inmates have it better than we do.” because the media and politicos have convincingly sold this lie as a fact to further their own agendas: elections and ratings. Myths of "country club prisons" keep this belief going, but only those who have lived behind prison walls know the truth. Cells are tiny, the toilet right there for all to watch. After all, humiliation is a form of punishment. Medical care and food quality are substandard. Commissary items, like shampoo, cost five times what they cost on the outside. Visiting conditions are often dehumanizing for both the inmate and the visitor. Guards turn a blind eye to prison rape. Loneliness is epidemic. Suicide is common. And false bravado becomes the inmate's persona. Punishment is emphasized over rehabilitation, so new skills learned in prison to help inmates upon release (and more than 90% WILL be released) are more likely to become "how to be a better criminal" rather than "how to read and write" since many prisons make little effort to offer educational programs. Illiteracy is higher in prisons than on the outside. So is mental illiness. But hey, let's lock 'em up and throw away the key!

Let me pose this question: If you knew that providing inmates with more amenities would reduce crime on a national level, would you be for it? If you could be shown actual facts and figures, what would you say? The idea of an inmate even wanting anything more than essentials necessary for survival borders on criminal to some. Well, meet Halden Prison YouTube - World's Nicest Prison: Halden Prison, Norway, Norway’s response to incarceration. It is a humane and ecological prison, the first of its kind. This is a country club prison if there ever was one. Perhaps this is what many Americans are confusing with prisons like San Quentin and Attica here in America? While this prison may seem extreme in a different direction entirely, you cannot deny the fact that Norway’s recidivism rate is much better than our own. Compare their recidivism rate of 20% after two years to that of America at 60%. Now I’m not suggesting movie theaters or ski lifts (climate permitting) in prison, but there is a lesson to be learned here. If we treated current or formerly incarcerated people more like people instead of a different species, perhaps they would be more inclined to act like people. Maybe if we didn’t slam the door in their face at the question “Have you ever been incarcerated?” perhaps they’d be more likely to work for their money instead of take it. I would be willing to wager that many inmates would gladly embrace a second opportunity at life if one were given. Many inmates have, but we are certainly not making it easy on them as a nation. The "lock 'em up and throw away the key" mentality will likely remain alive and well... until it is affecting someone you love. And hey... with the U.S. the most incarcerated nation on the planet (10 of all American men will at some point be locked up), the chance is good that someone you love will someday experience incarceration in a U.S. prison.
Vixxxen00, SeaCaptDon and zorie like this.
Categories
Uncategorized

Comments

  1. Numbercruncher's Avatar
    Adam, thank you for posting this blog! I must admit the attitude towards inmates was certainly the attitude I had BEFORE writing to my penpal. As a self professed "right wing conservative" I beleived in the mentality of "more prisons/longer sentences". How foolish I was, and I only wish I was in a position to tell my story so that others can see this mentality not only hurts inmates (which no one seems to care about), but also society as a whole.

    This country is such a proponent of giving "second chances", and third, and fourth, except to inmates. It seems whenever anyone "wants to get their life together" we have all sorts of programs to help them out, which most would say is a good thing. But this mentality halts immediately at the doors of a prison. We, as a society, realize that investing in schools, colleges, scholarships, and any way to assist people to go to college will only help our society. We're able to see the true benefit of investing in "second chances". Yet, NO ONE will listen to truth about the prison system. In fact they are blind to it. The thought of giving inmates the chance at EDUCATION (which I am convinced will lead to lower recidivism) won't fly with politicians, who as you have pointed out paint a nasty picture of what prison is (which is true only in the "extreme" cases. As long as politicians make it their platform to deprive inmates of any chance at education, and "second chances", people will always drink the kool-aid and blindly follow the ideas of what they want society to beleive prison is. Most people in society don't truly KNOW the reality of the situation, until it's too late. Until they know someone in the system and then it's the ulitmate David/Golieth tale, which the "little guy" will, sadly, never win.

    We always see on prison shows the judge and those affected by the crime, "he got x years to sit and think about what he/she did". Well, that's fine, and I can assure you that's certainly what my pp does. He truly thinks about why he is in prison and the people that he hurt. But what next? It's like step 1 of a huge plan, and we haven't given them the directions or road maps. What happens when they are released? The system we have created dictates that getting your life back on track after a lengthy incarceration is almost next to impossible.

    You asked what if studies proved that actually investing in men/women in prison would reveal the truth that this would lower recidivism~would that change public opinion. Probably not as long as their are politically motivated bullies with "think tanker" types twisting the facts behind the numbers. It breaks my heart. The most it seems we can hope for is to take care of our loved ones in prison until they get out, and then try to put the pieces back together upon their release. The ones who have no one out here, seem destined to repeat their bahavior because, apparently, society thinks they aren't worthy of a second chance.

    The question that I think arises so often...is, what are WE supposed to do about it?? I have thought often that I would like to be involved with rallying behind this cause...but there doesn't seem to be any state capital rally for that (if there was, I'd be there!).

    Anyway, Adam, great blog.
    Webmaster and Vixxxen00 like this.
    Updated 03-23-2011 at 09:25 AM by Numbercruncher
  2. Webmaster's Avatar
    Thank you for the comment. That was all very well said, and I find myself in total agreement with you. The media uses this issue to sell advertising space. It’s why the headlines and stories are often written with such sensationalism. Perhaps we should be targeting these sensational prison stories each day posting comments of the untold prison reality? It’s one way to show people the other side of the coin. When I get this site finished (maybe another year), I plan on getting much more involved in trying to organize our people around prison activism. Right now, I’ve got my blinders on until all of these projects are done.

    Thanks again for the comment!
  3. SeaCaptDon's Avatar
    duplicate, sorry!
    Updated 03-24-2011 at 03:26 PM by SeaCaptDon (duplicate)
  4. SeaCaptDon's Avatar
    Adam,
    I could not have said it any better.
    On my way home from my mother's funeral last weekend, I stopped to visit a sister-in-law and her husband and we got into a discussion about the corrections systems in this country. He proclaimed himself as a very conservative guy and we started talking about "true conservative values". In the end we were in agreement, that the true conservative person would opt for the programs and systems that work, which in turn save the taxpayers money and grief over the long haul. When one looks at the statistics regarding the entire justice system in this country and more specifically the penal system, it is astonishing. And in the current round of budget cuts across the country in Federal and State governments, we can only expect it to get worse. One statistic I read reported that for every dollar spent on education in prisons, the taxpayer gets $127 in return in reduced recidivism, reduced crime rates and reduced costs of prison operations. There are many other similar statistics that show an intelligent person that the current system is a dismal failure.
    One of the things that we see happen is exactly as you wrote. If you make an ex-offender feel like a person with worth, they will live up to it. If you give them hope and a second chance with some support they will amaze you with their success. For instance giving them a job, helping them with education, providing individual counseling and family counseling and even helping them to get into their own home... they suddenly have pride in themselves and in their accomplishments and they set out to prove themselves to themselves and their families and neighbors and everyone else around them. They live up to what is expected of them. Unfortunately, the converse is true, when nothing is expected or failure is expected, they often live up to that also.
    Thank you my friend for your posting.
    BTW, I have been posting often on blogs or forums following news stories about prison programs and prison failures and the narrow minded assaults are amazing. If you promote any type of program other than lock 'em up and throw away the key, you are branded as a left wing lunatic or a bleeding heart liberal. And the old adage "My mind is made up, don't confuse me with the facts!" is prevalent, unfortunately.
    Webmaster likes this.
  5. Webmaster's Avatar
    I am so very sorry to hear of the loss of your mother. I hope that you and your family are doing as well as can be expected. That has to be very hard.

    I agree. The true conservative is going to want to save money, and that’s exactly what our country is not doing by pretending like these people go in and never come out. I think that many people tend to think of an organization as liberal when they hear that you help inmates. I completely disagree. I know that the thousands of prison ministries in this country, in my experience at least, tend to be made up of very conservative people. I would also say that while we get a lot of support from the ministries, we do get support from what many would define as liberal organizations. We’ve had this discussion publicly over here a few times, and I think we usually come to the agreement that our pen-pals and inmates are really about half and half – no different than the country itself - mainly because the "prison problem" is completely non-partisan and affects every kind of American. I’d love to take a poll sometime just to find the exact numbers, but from the tone of correspondence we receive and the organizations with whom we partner, this seems to be one area where everyone is in agreement - we must help reduce recidivism, and we need to determine why we send more people to prison than any other nation in the first place and deal with that. I have always set out to keep my personal political and religious views just that, personal. Incarceration is one of those things that usually has to hit home for most people to identify with it, and it does hit every type of person.

    There is no doubt that it is much more cost effective in the long run to put more money into education – kids, adults, and prisoners than it is to keep building prisons to warehouse people. Education is a preventative to prison and a deterrent to recidivism. We need prisons to reform inmates, something they used to do, but that has been all but eliminated with an emphasis more on punishment. And with the country in economic decline we're seeing all kinds of responses. We’re closing prisons right and left (I just read yesterday that two more will close in Florida), and we’re cutting funding for education. I think that we should have been spending more on education when we could have afforded it. It would have made for less need of prisons in the end. Now we’re experiencing mass financial crisis, and we’re in panic mode. We currently lack the ability to properly address this. That’s where I hope that we can really come in for some of these inmates. People working with inmates in a one on one environment can lead to advanced education, employment, housing, etc. for these people when they are released (and more than 90% are released). Basically, a healthy personal relationship during incarceration can provide all kinds of support that will help keep them from reoffending.

    We have actually just started collecting limited data from inmates on their education levels/aspirations. In the year ahead, we hope to add a free posting for inmates seeking help with their education through correspondence programs. I have many, many, ideas, and it if weren’t for my handicap of having only two arms, I’d be much further along today

    Thank you for the comment, and again, I am very sorry to hear about your mom.
  6. zorie's Avatar
    I would be willing to wager that many inmates would gladly embrace a second opportunity at life if one were given.

    *** Wonderful Blog I must add.. Mr Webmaster.. Bravo and hats off to ya. ( I will add my 2 cents to these few lines)

    I must say that in my years of corresponding with inmates ( been doing this yrs before I found this site) what I have been hearing from most of them now.. young guys in their 20's serving life sentences..
    ( found them on this site) they are soo remorseful for what they have done in the past.. they are actually saying that they wish they could have an opportunity to start over now.. because they realize what they have done was just dumb.. and they were not thinking..
    it amazes me to know the extent these guys are going to see which organization could review their case.. to see if they could get a 2nd chance at freedom..
    They would write to let me know what they would do differently if given another chance.. Its just mind blowing how society and even their own families cast these guys off for the crimes they have committed.

    Mr Webmaster, you are so correct when you said { The "lock 'em up and throw away the key" mentality will likely remain alive and well... until it is affecting someone you love. And hey... with the U.S. the most incarcerated nation on the planet (10 of all American men will at some point be locked up), the chance is good that someone you love will soerience incarceration in a U.S. prison}.

    This year I had one shocker... and I still think that I am recovering from it.
    Last year I had a prison personnel ( dont wanna give the exact rank of the person) making contact with me.. ( never fully understood how the person found me back then) but they made my life miserable.. by this I meant they told me all sorta things what they thought of me... well in no time I knew they were familiar with my mails to inmates...
    what a year I had with that person.. I played it safe at first because I felt " worried " they could find all my inmates/penfriends and make them miserable for no apparent reason.
    I could not report it, as I felt it would make matters worse for my incarcerated friends. So I simply bore all my agony for the love of them..
    This person would write to me telling me the meanest of things, how I needed a life, how I am not even nice, by this I realize they knew what I look like. and I mean they would go on and on..

    Well one day I stood up to them, because I spoke my mind.. and I pointed out to them I was not lonely as they thought. I dont need a man as they so thought. we all have different desires and passions and hubbies and what makes us drives.. I choose to do what I am doing , corresponding with inmates. I made the choice and I DO HAVE A LIFE.. ( I was furious by now)
    They ended the conversation by saying well I am simply just crazy then.

    This yr its amazing the extent the said person has gone through to get in touch with me yet again..
    SIMPLY BECAUSE THEY HAVE A FAMILY MEMBER WHO IS NOW INCARCERATED and they need someone who is " genuine"
    that will be a friend to that family member.
    I had to really laugh hard and long. because I thought they told me that once they are incarcerated they are all criminals and criminals need to be locked away and close out from the outside world.

    Well Happy to say I took up the challenge and I am now corresponding with that family member for them.. and I have received a warm note from the said prison personnel thanking me for really doing this for the family..

    So Mr Webmaster, Adam, I do hope my message can be of good cheer to you, that you are doing a wonderful service here on Earth, people will criticize you like crazy, but its not until they are placed in the situation of having a relative/family member imprisoned .. its not until then , can they really understand the need for better prison systems, better treatment.. rehabilitation, or the need to fully understand that inmates are still humans and that they need some form of communication with the outside world.
    Webmaster likes this.
    Updated 09-04-2012 at 10:45 PM by zorie
  7. Webmaster's Avatar
    That was very well said, Zorie! Thank you for sharing And I am very sorry to hear of your harasser. It is sad how some people choose to spend their short time on this planet.
spacer
Visit our sponsors
Email  Report Problem 
BBB Chamber of Commerce
2000-2013 WriteAPrisoner.com, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Must be 18 to be viewing this website and have read our Terms of Service.